Choose The Pizza Plan
- Separate choices: Pizza Lobo’s 10-inch build-your-own pizzas let each person choose a sauce and toppings.
- Detroit-style: Paulie Gee’s Logan Square has a dedicated Logan Squares menu, with limited reservations.
- The mushroom order: Middle Brow’s mushroom pizza is a distinct order with mushroom cream, onions and fontina; count its service charge before comparing.
| Restaurant | Food Reference In USD | What To Decide First |
|---|---|---|
| Pizza Lobo — Logan Square | 10-inch base 11; 16-inch base 20, toppings extra | Separate personal orders or one larger pie |
| Paulie Gee’s — Logan Square | Current dining-room prices not verified | Detroit-style square or wood-fired round |
| Middle Brow Bungalow | Mushroom 25; approximately 30.28 with 21.1% service | Whether that shared order and added charge fit |
Checked October 14, 2026. These are pizza prices, not complete meal estimates. Tax, drinks and additional food are excluded. Tip is additional where applicable; Middle Brow says no tipping is necessary with its service charge. Different sizes and recipes are not equivalent portions.
Pizza Lobo When Everyone Wants Their Own Toppings
The useful line on Pizza Lobo’s Logan Square menu is the 10-inch personal base at USD 11. Two plain personal pizzas total USD 22; the 16-inch base is USD 20. Both are listed with shredded mozzarella and a choice of red sauce, vodka sauce or garlic oil, with toppings charged separately. That lets you settle the topping argument by ordering separately, without pretending the two options contain equal amounts of pizza.
Choose this branch when the group wants control over individual orders. It is at 3000 W Fullerton Avenue, with daily noon-to-midnight hours, but the official information page switches to slices only after 11 p.m. Friday and Saturday online ordering stops at 5 p.m.; phone pickup remains listed. A USD 25 tab preauthorization is a temporary authorization, not an additional pizza price; tabs left open close with 20% gratuity.
Paulie Gee’s For A Detroit-Style Decision
Paulie Gee’s Logan Square is the choice when the pizza style matters more than everyone getting a personal round. Its Logan Squares section includes Easy Cheesy, made with white cheddar, whole-milk mozzarella, Italian tomatoes and Pecorino Romano. Wood-fired rounds are a separate part of the menu: Hellboy combines fresh mozzarella, tomatoes, soppressata picante, Parmigiano-Reggiano and hot honey. Choose the style first; the toppings can follow.
This is 2451 N Milwaukee Avenue, rather than the Wicker Park slice shop. Limited reservations are available, and the restaurant links a limited pickup menu. Current dining-room prices and its current dining-room service-charge rate were not verified, so it is not ranked as the cheaper option here. Monday–Thursday service starts at 5 p.m.; Saturday and Sunday start at 11 a.m. Use the regular Logan Square menu when planning the order; its listed specials have a separate date range.
Middle Brow For A Mushroom Pizza With The Charge Counted
The mushroom pizza at Middle Brow Bungalow puts mushroom cream sauce, caramelized onions, fontina, oyster mushrooms and chives on one order. At USD 25, it becomes approximately USD 30.28 after the posted 21.1% service charge, before tax. That is a more useful comparison than stopping at the menu price. The restaurant says no tipping is necessary; drinks and other food still add to the bill.
Choose 2840 W Armitage Avenue when that mushroom-led order appeals to the table. The regular dinner menu also lists a USD 23 margherita with fresh mozzarella and basil, approximately USD 27.85 with service. Reserve through the official Resy link and check the menu for your service: Tuesday is advertised separately as Tavern Tuesday, and morning opening does not establish that dinner pizzas are available then. The restaurant is cashless and closed Monday.
Settle The Format Before The Bill
For different topping preferences, start with Lobo’s personal-pizza menu. If someone specifically wants Detroit-style, choose Paulie Gee’s and confirm the current price before setting a ceiling. For the mushroom order to share, Middle Brow supplies both the ingredients and an added-charge rate you can actually calculate. Add sides according to appetite; there is no reliable two-person portion rule across these three formats.
For more separate-pizza options nearby, see pizza for two in Wicker Park and Bucktown. Browse Logan Square meal plans for evenings that do not revolve around pizza.
These recommendations were researched from official branch websites, menus and booking information on October 14, 2026. They are not based on Top Food Spots restaurant visits or taste tests.