So how does this work?
We pick our top choices based on the quality of the food, service, and consistency over time. We’ll start off by giving you the best options overall for dining in Indianapolis and then follow up with links to different types of restaurants in different neighborhoods at the end of this page.
Best Italian Restaurants Indianapolis
Fazoli’s Description: Italian fast-food chain for pasta & subs. Fast-food chain doling out baked pastas, subs, pizza & other casual Italian fare plus custom combos. Address: 8401 Madison Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46227, United States Phone Number: +1 317-865-1204 Website: https://locations.fazolis.com/in/indianapolis/8401-s–madison-avenue.html?utm_source=yext+GMB&utm_medium=local&utm_campaign=website&y_source=1_MzExNzEzOC03MTUtbG9jYXRpb24uZ29vZ2xlX3dlYnNpdGVfb3ZlcnJpZGU%3D Store Hours: Sunday: 10:30AM-10PM | Monday: 10:30AM-10PM | Tuesday: 10:30AM-10PM | Wednesday: 10:30AM-10PM | Thursday: …
Pasta Americana Description: . Address: 7940 US-31 Suite B, Indianapolis, IN 46227, United States Phone Number: +1 317-885-5801 Website: http://pastaamericana.com/ Store Hours: Sunday: 11AM-10PM | Monday: 11AM-10PM | Tuesday: 11AM-10PM | Wednesday: 11AM-10PM | Thursday: 11AM-10PM | Friday: 11AM-11PM | Saturday: 11AM-11PM
Catello’s Italian Art Cuisine Description: . Address: 4901 E 82nd St, Indianapolis, IN 46250, United States Phone Number: +1 317-516-5766 Website: https://www.catellos.com/ Store Hours: Sunday: Closed | Monday: 11:30AM-2PM, 5-10PM | Tuesday: 11:30AM-2PM, 5-10PM | Wednesday: 11:30AM-2PM, 5-10PM | Thursday: 11:30AM-2PM, 5-10PM | Friday: 11:30AM-2PM, 5-11PM | Saturday: 11:30AM-2PM, 5-11PM
Olive Garden Italian Restaurant Description: Family-friendly Italian restaurant chain. Lively, family-friendly chain featuring Italian standards such as pastas & salads. Address: 8155 E Washington St, Indianapolis, IN 46219, United States Phone Number: +1 317-895-0800 Website: https://www.olivegarden.com/locations/in/indianapolis/indianapolis-east-washington-street/1043?cmpid=br:og_ag:ie_ch:loc_ca:OGGMB_sn:gmb_gt:indianapolis-in-1043_pl:locurl_rd:1021 Store Hours: Sunday: 11AM-10PM | Monday: 11AM-10PM | Tuesday: 11AM-10PM | Wednesday: 11AM-10PM | Thursday: 11AM-10PM | Friday: 11AM-11PM …
Byrne’s Grilled Pizza Description: . Address: 5615 N Illinois St, Indianapolis, IN 46208, United States Phone Number: +1 317-737-2056 Website: https://byrnespizza.com/ Store Hours: Sunday: 10AM-9PM | Monday: Closed | Tuesday: 11AM-9PM | Wednesday: 11AM-9PM | Thursday: 11AM-9PM | Friday: 11AM-10PM | Saturday: 11AM-10PM
Mauricio’s Pizzeria Description: . Address: 222 E Market St # 10, Indianapolis, IN 46204, United States Phone Number: +1 317-423-2920 Website: https://mauriciospizzeria.business.site/?utm_source=gmb&utm_medium=referral Store Hours: Sunday: Closed | Monday: 10AM-2PM | Tuesday: 10AM-2PM | Wednesday: 10AM-2PM | Thursday: 10AM-2PM | Friday: 10AM-2PM | Saturday: Closed
Nicolino’s Restaurant & Lounge Description: Italian classics in genteel hotel digs. Old-world Italian venue at Wyndham Indianapolis West serving Tuscan-inspired seafood & steak dishes. Address: 2544 Executive Dr, Indianapolis, IN 46241, United States Phone Number: +1 317-381-6146 Website: https://www.ordernicolinositalianrestaurant.com/ Store Hours: Sunday: 7AM-1PM, 4-9PM | Monday: 6:30-10AM, 11AM-1PM, 4-9PM | Tuesday: 6:30-10AM, 11AM-1PM, 4-9PM | …
King Dough Description: . Address: 452 N Highland Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46202, United States Phone Number: +1 317-602-7960 Website: Welcome Store Hours: Sunday: 11AM-9PM | Monday: Closed | Tuesday: 4-9PM | Wednesday: 4-9PM | Thursday: 11AM-9PM | Friday: 11AM-8PM | Saturday: 11AM-10PM
Fresco Italian Cafe on the Canal Description: Italian sandwiches, pizza & gelato. Casual spot for sandwiches, flatbread pizza, Italian ice & gelato, plus beer, wine & gondola rides. Address: 340 W Michigan St, Indianapolis, IN 46202, United States Phone Number: +1 317-797-9185 Website: Store Hours: Sunday: 11AM-7PM | Monday: Closed | Tuesday: Closed | Wednesday: …
Piada Italian Street Food Description: Customizable Italian fast food. Counter-order chain serving design-your-own Italian food including wraps, pastas & salads. Address: 8601 River Crossing Blvd, Indianapolis, IN 46204, United States Phone Number: +1 317-581-9955 Website: https://mypiada.com/menu/keystone Store Hours: Sunday: 10:45AM-10PM | Monday: 10:45AM-10PM | Tuesday: 10:45AM-10PM | Wednesday: 10:45AM-10PM | Thursday: 10:45AM-10PM | Friday: 10:45AM-8PM …
Buca di Beppo Italian Restaurant Description: Chain serving family-style Italian fare. Chain serving family-style Italian fare in a kitschy setting featuring red-&-white tablecloths. Address: 6045 E 86th St, Indianapolis, IN 46250, United States Phone Number: +1 317-842-8666 Website: https://locations.bucadibeppo.com/us/in/indianapolis/6045-e-86th-st?utm_source=google&utm_campaign=local-listing&utm_medium=organic&utm_content=gmb&y_source=1_NDgxNzYzOC03MTUtbG9jYXRpb24uZ29vZ2xlX3dlYnNpdGVfb3ZlcnJpZGU%3D Store Hours: Sunday: 11AM-9:30PM | Monday: 11AM-9:30PM | Tuesday: 11AM-9:30PM | Wednesday: 11AM-9:30PM | Thursday: 11AM-10PM …
Brozinni Pizzeria Description: Casual option for New York-style pizza. Family-friendly pizza place features the Big Apple’s signature crust & a small menu of Italian eats. Address: 8810 S Emerson Ave # 240, Indianapolis, IN 46237, United States Phone Number: +1 317-865-0911 Website: http://www.brozinni.com/ Store Hours: Sunday: 3-8PM | Monday: Closed | Tuesday: 11AM-8PM | Wednesday: …
Giorgio’s Pizza Description: Casual counter joint for pies & pasta. Thin- & thick-crust pizza & subs from an Italian-born chef, plus beer & wine in a quick-serve space. Address: 9 E Market St, Indianapolis, IN 46204, United States Phone Number: +1 317-687-9869 Website: https://giorgiospizzatogo.com/ Store Hours: Sunday: Closed | Monday: 10AM-9PM | Tuesday: 10AM-9PM | …
Goodfellas Pizzeria – Mass Ave Description: . Address: 545 Massachusetts Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46204, United States Phone Number: +1 317-602-3401 Website: http://www.goodfellaspizzeria.com/ Store Hours: Sunday: 11AM-12AM | Monday: Closed | Tuesday: 11AM-12AM | Wednesday: 11AM-12AM | Thursday: 11AM-12AM | Friday: 11AM-3AM | Saturday: Closed
Amore! Italian Kitchen Description: . Address: 9757 Fall Creek Rd, Indianapolis, IN 46256, United States Phone Number: +1 317-643-9494 Website: https://www.amoreitaliankitchenindy.com/ Store Hours: Sunday: 4-9PM | Monday: Closed | Tuesday: 4-9:30PM | Wednesday: 4-9:30PM | Thursday: 4-9:30PM | Friday: 4-10PM | Saturday: Closed
Napolese Pizzeria Description: Bustling pizzeria with inventive pies. Artisanal pizzas & Italian bites served with beer, wine & cocktails in modern surroundings. Address: 114 E 49th St, Indianapolis, IN 46205, United States Phone Number: +1 317-925-0765 Website: http://www.napolesepizzeria.com/ Store Hours: Sunday: 5-9PM | Monday: 5-9PM | Tuesday: 5-9PM | Wednesday: 5-9PM | Thursday: 5-9PM | …
Ambrosia Description: Stylish Italian restaurant with a patio. Upmarket Italian cuisine served in a classy, contemporary restaurant with patio seating. Address: 5903 N College Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46220, United States Phone Number: +1 317-255-3096 Website: http://www.ambrosiaindy.com/ Store Hours: Sunday: 5-9PM | Monday: 5-10PM | Tuesday: 5-10PM | Wednesday: 5-10PM | Thursday: 5-10PM | Friday: 5-11PM …
Capri Italian Restaurant Description: Long-running, classy Italian restaurant. Classy, long-running restaurant featuring Italian cuisine & wine plus a greenery-laden patio. Address: 2602 Ruth Dr, Indianapolis, IN 46240, United States Phone Number: +1 317-259-4122 Website: Front Page Store Hours: Sunday: 4-9PM | Monday: 11AM-2PM, 4-9PM | Tuesday: 4-9PM | Wednesday: 4-9PM | Thursday: 4-9PM | Friday: …
Maialina Italian Kitchen + Bar Description: Italian standards in a spacious locale. Traditional Italian cuisine is complemented by wine at this roomy, industrial-style haunt. Address: 1103 Prospect St, Indianapolis, IN 46203, United States Phone Number: +1 317-982-7676 Website: http://www.maialinaindy.com/ Store Hours: Sunday: 5-9PM | Monday: Closed | Tuesday: 5-9PM | Wednesday: 5-9PM | Thursday: 5-9PM …
Sangiovese Ristorante Description: Romantic Italian haunt with live jazz. Upscale, romantic Italian restaurant featuring a waterfront patio, a fireplace & jazz piano music. Address: 2727 E 86th St #110, Indianapolis, IN 46240, United States Phone Number: +1 317-757-5913 Website: Homepage Store Hours: Sunday: 5-8:30PM | Monday: 5-8:30PM | Tuesday: 5-8:30PM | Wednesday: 5-8:30PM | Thursday: …
Mama Carolla’s Description: Romantic Italian dining destination. Upscale Italian restaurant in a 1920s Mediterranean-style villa offering a full bar & a garden. Address: 1031 E 54th St, Indianapolis, IN 46220, United States Phone Number: +1 317-259-9412 Website: http://www.mamacarollas.com/ Store Hours: Sunday: Closed | Monday: Closed | Tuesday: Closed | Wednesday: Closed | Thursday: Closed | …
Buca di Beppo Description: Chain serving family-style Italian fare. Chain serving family-style Italian fare in a kitschy setting featuring red-&-white tablecloths. Address: 35 N Illinois St, Indianapolis, IN 46204, United States Phone Number: +1 317-632-2822 Website: https://locations.bucadibeppo.com/us/in/indianapolis/35-n-illinois-st?utm_source=google&utm_campaign=local-listing&utm_medium=organic&utm_content=gmb&y_source=1_NDgxNzYyMi03MTUtbG9jYXRpb24uZ29vZ2xlX3dlYnNpdGVfb3ZlcnJpZGU%3D Store Hours: Sunday: 11AM-9:30PM | Monday: 4-9PM | Tuesday: 4-9PM | Wednesday: 4-9PM | Thursday: 4-9PM | Friday: …
Bazbeaux Description: Gourmet pizza, sandwiches & microbrews. Italian spot serving lunchtime pizza by the slice & a menu of gourmet pies, sandwiches & craft beer. Address: 333 Massachusetts Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46204, United States Phone Number: +1 317-636-7662 Website: http://www.bazbeaux.com/ Store Hours: Sunday: 11AM-9PM | Monday: 11AM-9PM | Tuesday: 11AM-9PM | Wednesday: 11AM-9PM | Thursday: …
The Old Spaghetti Factory Description: Italian eatery with old-fashioned decor. Family-friendly chain eatery featuring traditional Italian entrees amid turn-of-the-century decor. Address: 210 S Meridian St, Indianapolis, IN 46225, United States Phone Number: +1 317-635-6325 Website: http://www.osf.com/location/indianapolis-in/ Store Hours: Sunday: 12-9:30PM | Monday: 11AM-2PM, 5-9:30PM | Tuesday: 11AM-2PM, 5-9:30PM | Wednesday: 11AM-2PM, 5-9:30PM | Thursday: 11AM-2PM, …
Iozzo’s Garden of Italy Description: Pasta & wine in intimate modern setting. Storied eatery serves Italian classics & wine in its sophisticated dining room & quaint courtyard. Address: 946 S Meridian St, Indianapolis, IN 46225, United States Phone Number: +1 317-974-1100 Website: http://www.iozzos.com/ Store Hours: Sunday: 4-8PM | Monday: Closed | Tuesday: 11AM-9PM | Wednesday: …
Iaria’s Italian Restaurant Description: Iconic pizza parlor with red-sauce eats. Open since 1933, this extra-homey, family-run institution dishes up classic pasta dinners & pizzas. Address: 317 S College Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46202, United States Phone Number: +1 317-638-7706 Website: http://www.iariasrestaurant.com/ Store Hours: Sunday: Closed | Monday: Closed | Tuesday: 4:30-9PM | Wednesday: 4:30-9PM | Thursday: …
Sauce on the Side Description: . Address: 130 S Pennsylvania St Suite 2, Indianapolis, IN 46204, United States Phone Number: +1 317-757-2859 Website: Home Store Hours: Sunday: 12-8PM | Monday: 11AM-9PM | Tuesday: 11AM-9PM | Wednesday: 11AM-9PM | Thursday: 11AM-9PM | Friday: 11AM-8PM | Saturday: 12-8PM
Maggiano’s Little Italy Description: Chain for family-style Italian meals. Semi-upscale chain for classic Italian fare served family-style in a relaxed, polished space. Address: 3550 E 86th St, Indianapolis, IN 46240, United States Phone Number: +1 317-814-0700 Website: https://www.maggianos.com/indiana/indianapolis/3550-e.-86th-st./?utm_source=google&utm_medium=organic&utm_campaign=localmaps Store Hours: Sunday: 11AM-9PM | Monday: 11AM-10PM | Tuesday: 11AM-10PM | Wednesday: 11AM-10PM | Thursday: 11AM-10PM | …
Bluebeard Description: Hip setup for creative sharing plates. Trendy New American kitchen serving sharing plates & craft cocktails in a renovated 1924 warehouse. Address: 653 Virginia Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46203, United States Phone Number: +1 317-686-1580 Website: Home Store Hours: Sunday: 4-10PM | Monday: Closed | Tuesday: 11AM-10PM | Wednesday: 11AM-10PM | Thursday: 11AM-10PM | …