So how does this work?
We pick our top choices based on the quality of the food, service, and consistency over time. We’ll start off by giving you the best options overall for dining in Tallahassee and then follow up with links to different types of restaurants in different neighborhoods at the end of this page.
Best Italian Restaurants Tallahassee
Mom & Dad’s Italian Restaurant Description: . Address: 3421 Bannerman Rd Suite #104, Tallahassee, FL 32312, United States Phone Number: +1 850-877-4518 Website: http://www.momanddadstally.com/ Store Hours: Sunday: 4-8PM | Monday: 4:30-9PM | Tuesday: 4:30-9PM | Wednesday: 4:30-9PM | Thursday: 4:30-9PM | Friday: 4:30-10PM | Saturday: 5-10PM
Red Elephant Pizza & Grill Description: Pizza & other American grub. Made-to-order pizzas, American fare & a kids’ menu in a lively setting with arcade games. Address: 2910 Kerry Forest Pkwy, Tallahassee, FL 32309, United States Phone Number: +1 850-668-7492 Website: http://www.redelephantpizza.com/ Store Hours: Sunday: 11AM-8PM | Monday: 11AM-8PM | Tuesday: 11AM-8PM | Wednesday: 11AM-8PM …
Hungry Howie’s Pizza Description: Pizzeria chain known for flavored crusts. Basic, counter-serve pizzeria chain popular for its flavored crusts, such as sesame & garlic herb. Address: 3551 N Blair Stone Rd #7, Tallahassee, FL 32301, United States Phone Number: +1 850-671-3400 Website: http://www.hungryhowies.com/store/03044 Store Hours: Sunday: 11AM-10PM | Monday: 10AM-10PM | Tuesday: 10AM-10PM | Wednesday: …
Hungry Howie’s Pizza Description: Pizzeria chain known for flavored crusts. Basic, counter-serve pizzeria chain popular for its flavored crusts, such as sesame & garlic herb. Address: Next to Best Buy, 1496 Apalachee Pkwy, Tallahassee, FL 32301, United States Phone Number: +1 850-942-6800 Website: http://www.hungryhowies.com/store/00245 Store Hours: Sunday: 11AM-11PM | Monday: 10AM-11PM | Tuesday: 10AM-11PM | …
Hungry Howie’s Pizza Description: Pizzeria chain known for flavored crusts. Basic, counter-serve pizzeria chain popular for its flavored crusts, such as sesame & garlic herb. Address: Plaza/Publix, 3111 Mahan Drive Lafayette, Tallahassee, FL 32308, United States Phone Number: +1 850-877-8999 Website: http://hungryhowies.com/store/00206 Store Hours: Sunday: 11AM-11PM | Monday: 10AM-11PM | Tuesday: 10AM-11PM | Wednesday: 10AM-11PM …
Pizza Mouth Description: Straightforward option for pies & wings. Informal chain offering an extensive menu of pizza, wings & Italian comfort food. Address: 623 W Tennessee St, Tallahassee, FL 32304, United States Phone Number: +1 850-886-6884 Website: https://order.incentivio.com/c/pizzamouth/ Store Hours: Sunday: 4PM-1AM | Monday: 4PM-2AM | Tuesday: 4PM-2AM | Wednesday: 4PM-2AM | Thursday: 4PM-2AM | …
Village Pizza & Pasta Description: No-frills mainstay for NYC-style pizza. Strip-mall fixture offering New York–style pies, pasta & other Italian eats in a laid-back setting. Address: 1400 Village Square Blvd #33, Tallahassee, FL 32312, United States Phone Number: +1 850-893-9001 Website: https://villagepizzaandpasta.com/ Store Hours: Sunday: 11AM-9PM | Monday: Closed | Tuesday: 11AM-10PM | Wednesday: 11AM-10PM …
Gaines Street Pies Description: Easygoing joint with pizza & craft beer. Chill pizzeria featuring craft brews & a menu that includes sandwiches, wraps & appetizers. Address: 603 W Gaines St #3, Tallahassee, FL 32304, United States Phone Number: +1 850-765-9275 Website: http://www.gainesstreetpies.com/ Store Hours: Sunday: 11AM-1AM | Monday: 11AM-1AM | Tuesday: 11AM-1AM | Wednesday: 11AM-1AM …
Brickyard Pizzeria Description: . Address: 4819 Kerry Forest Pkwy, Tallahassee, FL 32309, United States Phone Number: +1 850-562-7425 Website: http://www.brickyardpizzeria.com/ Store Hours: Sunday: 4-9PM | Monday: 4-9PM | Tuesday: 11AM-2:30PM, 4:30-10PM | Wednesday: 11AM-2:30PM, 4:30-10PM | Thursday: 11AM-2:30PM, 4:30-10PM | Friday: 11AM-2:30PM, 4:30-10PM | Saturday: 11AM-2:30PM, 4:30-10PM
Milano Pizzeria Description: Casual counter-serve for NY-style pizza. Family-run pizzeria with a patio serving NY-style pies & Italian eats at the counter in simple digs. Address: 514 W Tharpe St, Tallahassee, FL 32303, United States Phone Number: +1 850-270-9100 Website: https://themilanopizzeria.com/ Store Hours: Sunday: 11AM-9PM | Monday: Closed | Tuesday: 11AM-10PM | Wednesday: 11AM-10PM | …
Riccardo’s Restaurant Description: Cozy Italian bistro with homemade bread. Quaint strip-mall eatery for sandwiches on housemade bread, pizza & other Italian entrees. Address: 1950 Thomasville Rd # G, Tallahassee, FL 32303, United States Phone Number: +1 850-386-3988 Website: Home Store Hours: Sunday: Closed | Monday: Closed | Tuesday: Closed | Wednesday: Closed | Thursday: Closed …
Little Italy Description: Comfy mainstay for classic Italian meals. Family-owned haunt providing a selection of traditional Italian dishes in a comfortable atmosphere. Address: 111 S Magnolia Dr #17, Tallahassee, FL 32301, United States Phone Number: +1 850-878-7781 Website: https://www.littleitalytlh.com/ Store Hours: Sunday: Closed | Monday: 11AM-9PM | Tuesday: 11AM-9PM | Wednesday: 11AM-9PM | Thursday: 11AM-9PM …
Midtown Pies Description: Inventive pizza & heros, open late. Lofty, late-closing parlor serving creative pizza, Italian sandwiches & draft beer. Address: 1122 Thomasville Rd #4, Tallahassee, FL 32303, United States Phone Number: +1 850-765-4120 Website: http://midtownpies.com/ Store Hours: Sunday: 11AM-10PM | Monday: 11AM-10PM | Tuesday: 11AM-10PM | Wednesday: 11AM-10PM | Thursday: 11AM-10PM | Friday: 11AM-10PM …
IL Lusso Description: Polished eatery with Italian dishes. Airy, upscale restaurant furnishing Italian-style meat & seafood mains, plus pasta & small plates. Address: 201 E Park Ave #100, Tallahassee, FL 32301, United States Phone Number: +1 850-765-8620 Website: https://www.illussotlh.com/ Store Hours: Sunday: Closed | Monday: 5-9PM | Tuesday: 5-9PM | Wednesday: 5-9PM | Thursday: 5-9PM …
Carrabba’s Italian Grill Description: Family-friendly chain with a large menu. Chain eatery & bar serving a diverse menu of classic Italian fare in a family-friendly setting. Address: 2779 Capital Cir NE, Tallahassee, FL 32308, United States Phone Number: +1 850-297-1100 Website: https://locations.carrabbas.com/florida/tallahassee/2779-capital-circle-ne Store Hours: Sunday: 11AM-9PM | Monday: 11AM-10PM | Tuesday: 11AM-10PM | Wednesday: 11AM-10PM …
Olive Garden Italian Restaurant Description: Family-friendly Italian restaurant chain. Lively, family-friendly chain featuring Italian standards such as pastas & salads. Address: 1103 Apalachee Pkwy, Tallahassee, FL 32301, United States Phone Number: +1 850-878-2949 Website: https://www.olivegarden.com/locations/fl/tallahassee/tallahassee/1236?cmpid=br:og_ag:ie_ch:loc_ca:OGGMB_sn:gmb_gt:tallahassee-fl-1236_pl:locurl_rd:1176 Store Hours: Sunday: 11AM-10PM | Monday: 11AM-10PM | Tuesday: 11AM-10PM | Wednesday: 11AM-10PM | Thursday: 11AM-10PM | Friday: 11AM-11PM | …
Mom & Dad’s Italian Restaurant Description: . Address: 3421 Bannerman Rd Suite #104, Tallahassee, FL 32312, United States Phone Number: +1 850-877-4518 Website: http://www.momanddadstally.com/ Store Hours: Sunday: 4-8PM | Monday: 4:30-9PM | Tuesday: 4:30-9PM | Wednesday: 4:30-9PM | Thursday: 4:30-9PM | Friday: 4:30-10PM | Saturday: 5-10PM
Bella Bella Description: Hip Italian cafe with outdoor seating. Italian fare, craft beers & cocktails served up in funky digs with outdoor seating. Address: 123 E 5th Ave, Tallahassee, FL 32303, United States Phone Number: +1 850-412-1114 Website: https://www.thebellabella.com/ Store Hours: Sunday: Closed | Monday: 4-9:30PM | Tuesday: 4-9:30PM | Wednesday: 4-9:30PM | Thursday: 4-9:30PM …
Z Bardhi’s Italian Cuisine Description: Classy eatery for pizza & wine. White-tablecloth Italian restaurant with outdoor seating offering many wines & specialty pizzas. Address: 3596 Kinhega Dr, Tallahassee, FL 32312, United States Phone Number: +1 850-894-9919 Website: http://www.zbardhis.com/ Store Hours: Sunday: 11AM-2PM, 5-9:30PM | Monday: Closed | Tuesday: Closed | Wednesday: 5-9:30PM | Thursday: 5-9:30PM …
Tour of Italy Description: . Address: 3813 N Monroe St Suite 21, Tallahassee, FL 32303, United States Phone Number: +1 850-727-8794 Website: https://www.tourofitalykitchen.com/menus.html Store Hours: Sunday: Closed | Monday: Closed | Tuesday: 11AM-3PM, 4-9PM | Wednesday: 11AM-3PM, 4-9PM | Thursday: 11AM-3PM, 4-9PM | Friday: 11AM-3PM, 4-9PM | Saturday: 12-9PM