So how does this work?
We pick our top choices based on the quality of the food, service, and consistency over time. We’ll start off by giving you the best options overall for dining in Lancaster and then follow up with links to different types of restaurants in different neighborhoods at the end of this page.
Best Italian Restaurants Lancaster
Olive Garden Italian Restaurant Description: Family-friendly Italian restaurant chain. Lively, family-friendly chain featuring Italian standards such as pastas & salads. Address: 910 Plaza Blvd, Lancaster, PA 17601, United States Phone Number: +1 717-299-2202 Website: https://www.olivegarden.com/locations/pa/lancaster/lancaster-park-city-mall/1383?cmpid=br:og_ag:ie_ch:loc_ca:OGGMB_sn:gmb_gt:lancaster-pa-1383_pl:locurl_rd:1288 Store Hours: Sunday: 11AM-10PM | Monday: 11AM-10PM | Tuesday: 11AM-10PM | Wednesday: 11AM-10PM | Thursday: 11AM-10PM | Friday: 11AM-11PM | …
Olive Garden Italian Restaurant Description: Family-friendly Italian restaurant chain. Lively, family-friendly chain featuring Italian standards such as pastas & salads. Address: 35 S Willowdale Dr Suite 1001, Lancaster, PA 17602, United States Phone Number: +1 717-392-3235 Website: https://www.olivegarden.com/locations/pa/lancaster/lancaster-rockvale-outlets/1742?cmpid=br:og_ag:ie_ch:loc_ca:OGGMB_sn:gmb_gt:lancaster-pa-1742_pl:locurl_rd:1591 Store Hours: Sunday: 11AM-10PM | Monday: 11AM-10PM | Tuesday: 11AM-10PM | Wednesday: 11AM-10PM | Thursday: 11AM-10PM | …
Gibraltar Restaurant Description: Mellow Mediterranean fine dining. Upscale Mediterranean spot for seafood, artisanal bread & vast wine list in a relaxed, lofty space. Address: 488 Royer Dr #101, Lancaster, PA 17601, United States Phone Number: +1 717-397-2790 Website: Home Store Hours: Sunday: Closed | Monday: Closed | Tuesday: 4:45-9PM | Wednesday: 4:45-9PM | Thursday: 4:45-9PM …
Carrabba’s Italian Grill Description: Family-friendly chain with a large menu. Chain eatery & bar serving a diverse menu of classic Italian fare in a family-friendly setting. Address: 100 N Pointe Blvd, Lancaster, PA 17601, United States Phone Number: +1 717-560-6756 Website: https://locations.carrabbas.com/pennsylvania/lancaster/100-north-pointe-blvd Store Hours: Sunday: 11AM-9PM | Monday: 11AM-10PM | Tuesday: 11AM-10PM | Wednesday: 11AM-10PM …
Lombardo’s Restaurant Description: Established spot for Italian classics. This family-owned restaurant has been serving Southern Italian specialties like lasagna since 1946. Address: 216 Harrisburg Ave, Lancaster, PA 17603, United States Phone Number: +1 717-394-3749 Website: Home Store Hours: Sunday: Closed | Monday: Closed | Tuesday: 11AM-2:30PM, 4-9:30PM | Wednesday: 11AM-2:30PM, 4-9:30PM | Thursday: 11AM-2:30PM, 4-9:30PM …
Pasquale’s Description: Authentic spot for classic pies & pastas. Made-to-order pizzas & pastas along with sandwiches & burgers offered in a casual setting. Address: 1657 Old Philadelphia Pike, Lancaster, PA 17602, United States Phone Number: +1 717-509-9921 Website: Pasquales Store Hours: Sunday: Closed | Monday: Closed | Tuesday: 10:30AM-10PM | Wednesday: 10:30AM-10PM | Thursday: 10:30AM-10PM …
LUCA Description: Refined Italian restaurant & pizzeria. Trendy, bustling venue for modern Italian dinners & wood-fired pizzas, plus beer, wine & cocktails. Address: 436 W James St #101, Lancaster, PA 17603, United States Phone Number: +1 717-553-5770 Website: Home Store Hours: Sunday: 4-9PM | Monday: Closed | Tuesday: Closed | Wednesday: 4-9PM | Thursday: 4-9PM …
Round Table Pizza Description: Chain eatery with build-your-own pizzas. Chain serving pizzas with a variety of toppings & sauces in a simple space. Address: 44204 10th St W, Lancaster, CA 93534, United States Phone Number: +1 661-945-6677 Website: https://ordering.roundtablepizza.com/site/rt222?utm_source=wisely&utm_medium=weblink&utm_campaign=222 Store Hours: Sunday: 11AM-9PM | Monday: 11AM-9PM | Tuesday: 11AM-9PM | Wednesday: 11AM-9PM | Thursday: 11AM-9PM …
Gia’s Pizza Description: . Address: 2072 W Ave J, Lancaster, CA 93536, United States Phone Number: +1 661-802-4120 Website: Home Store Hours: Sunday: 11AM-7PM | Monday: 11AM-9PM | Tuesday: 11AM-9PM | Wednesday: 11AM-9PM | Thursday: 11AM-9PM | Friday: 11AM-9PM | Saturday: 11AM-9PM
Barone’s Pizza Description: Casual Italian spot for specialty pies. Specialty pizzas, pastas & a variety of classic Italian entrees in a casual, strip-mall space. Address: 1229 W Ave I, Lancaster, CA 93534, United States Phone Number: +1 661-948-0771 Website: Home Store Hours: Sunday: 11AM-8:30PM | Monday: Closed | Tuesday: Closed | Wednesday: 11AM-8:30PM | Thursday: …
Captain Tony’s Pizza & Pasta Description: Casual pick for pies, pasta & wings. Pizzeria chain serving classic & creative pies, plus pasta & wings, in a casual setting. Address: Metro, 135 E Ave. J, Lancaster, CA 93535, United States Phone Number: +1 661-942-3000 Website: Lancaster California Store Hours: Sunday: 10:30AM-10PM | Monday: 10:30AM-10PM | Tuesday: …
Big Belly Pizza Company Description: . Address: 42458 60th St W #115, Lancaster, CA 93536, United States Phone Number: +1 661-941-3339 Website: http://www.bigbellypizzaco.com/ Store Hours: Sunday: 11AM-10PM | Monday: 11AM-10PM | Tuesday: 11AM-10PM | Wednesday: 11AM-10PM | Thursday: 11AM-10PM | Friday: 11AM-10PM | Saturday: 11AM-10PM
Gino’s Italian Restaurant Description: Pizza & Italian classics amid murals. An old-school Italian menu includes pizza & pasta in a sit-down, mural-clad space. Address: 44343 Challenger Way, Lancaster, CA 93535, United States Phone Number: +1 661-945-2791 Website: https://www.ginosrestaurantmenu.com/ Store Hours: Sunday: 11AM-9PM | Monday: 11AM-9PM | Tuesday: 11AM-9PM | Wednesday: 11AM-9PM | Thursday: 11AM-9PM | …
Gino’s Ristorante Description: Traditional fare in a spacious setup. Pizza, pasta & cocktails served in a large venue featuring a banquet room & patio with live music. Address: 44960 Valley Central Way, Lancaster, CA 93536, United States Phone Number: +1 661-942-1300 Website: https://www.ginoslancastermenu.com/ Store Hours: Sunday: 11AM-9PM | Monday: 11AM-9PM | Tuesday: 11AM-9PM | Wednesday: …
Lombardo’s Restaurant Description: Established spot for Italian classics. This family-owned restaurant has been serving Southern Italian specialties like lasagna since 1946. Address: 216 Harrisburg Ave, Lancaster, PA 17603, United States Phone Number: +1 717-394-3749 Website: Home Store Hours: Sunday: Closed | Monday: Closed | Tuesday: 11AM-2:30PM, 4-9:30PM | Wednesday: 11AM-2:30PM, 4-9:30PM | Thursday: 11AM-2:30PM, 4-9:30PM …
Sugar Bears Pizzeria Description: Simple stop for pies, pasta & subs. Unassuming eatery with kitschy decor offering thick-crust pies, simple pastas & sandwiches. Address: 147 Cedar Hill Rd, Lancaster, OH 43130, United States Phone Number: +1 740-689-1717 Website: Store Hours: Sunday: Closed | Monday: Closed | Tuesday: 11AM-7PM | Wednesday: 11AM-7PM | Thursday: 11AM-7PM | …
LUCA Description: Refined Italian restaurant & pizzeria. Trendy, bustling venue for modern Italian dinners & wood-fired pizzas, plus beer, wine & cocktails. Address: 436 W James St #101, Lancaster, PA 17603, United States Phone Number: +1 717-553-5770 Website: Home Store Hours: Sunday: 4-9PM | Monday: Closed | Tuesday: Closed | Wednesday: 4-9PM | Thursday: 4-9PM …
Cristy’s Pizza East Description: Easygoing stop for pies & subs. Unassuming eatery for pies, salads & subs, plus beer, wine, cocktails & a small outdoor patio. Address: 1436 Tiki Ln, Lancaster, OH 43130, United States Phone Number: +1 740-687-0770 Website: Cristy’s Pizza – Home Store Hours: Sunday: 11AM-11PM | Monday: 11AM-11PM | Tuesday: 11AM-11PM | …
Osteria Alla Romana Description: . Address: 1453 Tiki Ln, Lancaster, OH 43130, United States Phone Number: +1 740-785-9154 Website: Store Hours: Sunday: Closed | Monday: Closed | Tuesday: 11AM-9PM | Wednesday: 11AM-9PM | Thursday: 11AM-9PM | Friday: 11AM-9PM | Saturday: 11AM-9PM
Nick’s Restaurant & Pizza Description: . Address: 702 W Wheeling St, Lancaster, OH 43130, United States Phone Number: +1 740-653-3268 Website: http://facebook.com/nickspizzalancaster Store Hours: Sunday: Closed | Monday: 10AM-10PM | Tuesday: 10AM-10PM | Wednesday: 10AM-10PM | Thursday: 10AM-10PM | Friday: 10AM-10PM | Saturday: 7AM-10PM
Tiberios Description: . Address: 2610 N Columbus St, Lancaster, OH 43130, United States Phone Number: +1 740-654-2317 Website: Store Hours: Sunday: 4-8PM | Monday: 11AM-8PM | Tuesday: Closed | Wednesday: 11AM-8PM | Thursday: 11AM-8PM | Friday: 11AM-8PM | Saturday: 4-8PM
Pasquale’s Description: Authentic spot for classic pies & pastas. Made-to-order pizzas & pastas along with sandwiches & burgers offered in a casual setting. Address: 1657 Old Philadelphia Pike, Lancaster, PA 17602, United States Phone Number: +1 717-509-9921 Website: Pasquales Store Hours: Sunday: Closed | Monday: Closed | Tuesday: 10:30AM-10PM | Wednesday: 10:30AM-10PM | Thursday: 10:30AM-10PM …
Round Table Pizza Description: Chain eatery with build-your-own pizzas. Chain serving pizzas with a variety of toppings & sauces in a simple space. Address: 44204 10th St W, Lancaster, CA 93534, United States Phone Number: +1 661-945-6677 Website: https://ordering.roundtablepizza.com/site/rt222?utm_source=wisely&utm_medium=weblink&utm_campaign=222 Store Hours: Sunday: 11AM-10PM | Monday: 11AM-10PM | Tuesday: 11AM-10PM | Wednesday: 11AM-10PM | Thursday: 11AM-10PM …
Captain Tony’s Pizza & Pasta Description: Casual pick for pies, pasta & wings. Pizzeria chain serving classic & creative pies, plus pasta & wings, in a casual setting. Address: Metro, 135 E Ave. J, Lancaster, CA 93535, United States Phone Number: +1 661-942-3000 Website: Lancaster California Store Hours: Sunday: 10:30AM-10PM | Monday: 10:30AM-10PM | Tuesday: …
Big Belly Pizza Company Description: . Address: 42458 60th St W #115, Lancaster, CA 93536, United States Phone Number: +1 661-941-3339 Website: http://www.bigbellypizzaco.com/ Store Hours: Sunday: 11AM-9PM | Monday: 11AM-9PM | Tuesday: 11AM-9PM | Wednesday: 11AM-9PM | Thursday: 11AM-9PM | Friday: 11AM-10PM | Saturday: 11AM-10PM