So how does this work?
We pick our top choices based on the quality of the food, service, and consistency over time. We’ll start off by giving you the best options overall for dining in Columbus and then follow up with links to different types of restaurants in different neighborhoods at the end of this page.
Best Italian Restaurants Columbus
Buckeye Pizza & Stromboli Description: Pizzeria with New York–style pies. Straightforward pizzeria with New York–style pies, stromboli, subs & salads, plus delivery. Address: 4434 Westerville Rd, Columbus, OH 43231, United States Phone Number: +1 614-471-7777 Website: https://www.buckeyepizzastromboli.com/ Store Hours: Sunday: Closed | Monday: 1-10PM | Tuesday: 1-10PM | Wednesday: Closed | Thursday: 1-10PM | Friday: …
Cottage Inn Pizza Columbus Description: Casual chain for pizza, subs & salads. Long-running Midwestern chain serving deep-dish & thin-crust pizzas, plus subs, salads & more. Address: 2167 N High St, Columbus, OH 43201, United States Phone Number: +1 614-564-9292 Website: https://order.cottageinn.com/?uniqueStoreIdentifier=COLUMBUS&y_source=1_MTU1NDQzMjgtNzE1LWxvY2F0aW9uLmdvb2dsZV93ZWJzaXRlX292ZXJyaWRl#/ Store Hours:
Panzera’s Pizza of Upper Arlington Description: . Address: 3794 Fairlington Dr, Columbus, OH 43220, United States Phone Number: +1 614-442-7930 Website: http://uapanzeras-com.webnode.com/ Store Hours: Sunday: 4:30-9PM | Monday: 5-9:30PM | Tuesday: 5-9:30PM | Wednesday: 5-9:30PM | Thursday: 5-9:30PM | Friday: 4:30-10:30PM | Saturday: 4:30-10:30PM
Panini Opa Description: Casual stop-in for Greek & Italian fare. Relaxed counter-serve eatery offering Greek & Italian pita sandwiches, platters & desserts. Address: 4799 Sawmill Rd, Columbus, OH 43235, United States Phone Number: +1 614-336-8830 Website: http://www.paniniopa.com/ Store Hours: Sunday: 11AM-10PM | Monday: 11AM-10PM | Tuesday: 11AM-10PM | Wednesday: 11AM-10PM | Thursday: 11AM-10PM | Friday: …
Minelli’s Pizza Description: . Address: 1189 N Wilson Rd, Columbus, OH 43204, United States Phone Number: +1 614-279-3344 Website: http://www.minellispizza.com/ Store Hours: Sunday: 11AM-10PM | Monday: 10:30AM-10PM | Tuesday: 10:30AM-10PM | Wednesday: 10:30AM-10PM | Thursday: 10:30AM-10PM | Friday: 10:30AM-11PM | Saturday: 11AM-11PM
Santino’s Pizzeria Description: . Address: 1675 Holt Rd, Columbus, OH 43228, United States Phone Number: +1 614-851-9600 Website: http://www.santinospizzeria.com/ Store Hours: Sunday: 11:30AM-9PM | Monday: 11:30AM-10PM | Tuesday: 11:30AM-10PM | Wednesday: 11:30AM-10PM | Thursday: 11:30AM-10PM | Friday: 11:30AM-10:45PM | Saturday: 11:30AM-10:45PM
The Berwick Banquet & Catering Description: . Address: 3250 Refugee Rd, Columbus, OH 43232, United States Phone Number: +1 614-235-7100 Website: http://www.the-berwick.com/ Store Hours: Sunday: Closed | Monday: 9AM-5PM | Tuesday: 9AM-5PM | Wednesday: 9AM-5PM | Thursday: 9AM-5PM | Friday: 9AM-5PM | Saturday: 10AM-5PM
Portofino’s Pizza Description: Unfussy pit stop for massive pies. No-frills nook offering large pies & casual grub for takeaway in a simple interior. Address: 1497 N High St, Columbus, OH 43201, United States Phone Number: +1 614-294-2949 Website: http://orderportofinospizza.com/ Store Hours: Sunday: 2-9PM | Monday: 10AM-9:45PM | Tuesday: 10AM-9:45PM | Wednesday: 10AM-9:45PM | Thursday: 10AM-9:45PM …
Paulie Gee’s Short North Description: . Address: 1195 N High St, Columbus, OH 43201, United States Phone Number: +1 614-808-0112 Website: http://pauliegee.com/short-north/ Store Hours: Sunday: 4-9PM | Monday: Closed | Tuesday: Closed | Wednesday: 5-10PM | Thursday: 5-10PM | Friday: 4-10PM | Saturday: 4-10PM
Big Tony’s Pizza & Pasta Description: Basic pizza joint offering delivery. Modest outlet offering pizza, pasta, sandwiches & salads, with delivery & takeout. Address: 1097 Worthington Woods Blvd, Columbus, OH 43085, United States Phone Number: +1 614-436-3777 Website: https://www.bigtonyspizzapasta.com/ Store Hours: Sunday: 12-9:45PM | Monday: 11AM-9:45PM | Tuesday: 11AM-9:45PM | Wednesday: 11AM-9:45PM | Thursday: 11AM-9:45PM …
Pizza Rustica Description: Late-night option for rectangular pies. Counter-serve chain offering Roman-style rectangular pies, slices & more until late at night. Address: 17 S High St, Columbus, OH 43215, United States Phone Number: +1 614-754-1459 Website: Welcome Store Hours: Sunday: Closed | Monday: 11AM-9PM | Tuesday: 11AM-9PM | Wednesday: 11AM-9PM | Thursday: 11AM-9PM | Friday: …
The Market: Food, Drink Description: Modern restaurant with a terrace. Contemporary restaurant with a terrace serving local dishes, plus monthly wine clubs. Address: 1022 Summit St, Columbus, OH 43201, United States Phone Number: +1 614-914-5544 Website: http://www.themarketiv.com/ Store Hours: Sunday: 5-9PM | Monday: Closed | Tuesday: Closed | Wednesday: 5-10PM | Thursday: 5-10PM | Friday: …
The Pizza House Description: Italian eats in a no-frills setting. Pasta, pizza, meatball subs & other Italian dishes in a simple, brightly lit diner. Address: 747 E Lincoln Ave, Columbus, OH 43229, United States Phone Number: +1 614-885-3121 Website: http://www.pizzahousecolumbus.com/ Store Hours: Sunday: 3-8PM | Monday: 11AM-8PM | Tuesday: 11AM-8PM | Wednesday: 11AM-8PM | Thursday: …
Smith’s Restaurant and Deli Description: Family-run place for sandwiches & more. Established in 1960, this cozy, family-owned eatery offers hearty sandwiches, pasta & pizza. Address: 3737 N High St, Columbus, OH 43214, United States Phone Number: +1 614-267-7541 Website: http://smithsdeli.com/ Store Hours: Sunday: Closed | Monday: 9AM-9PM | Tuesday: 9AM-9PM | Wednesday: 9AM-9PM | Thursday: …
Dante’s Pizza Description: Long-running choice for pies & pasta. Cozy, neighborhood parlor offering pizza, pasta, subs & other Italian fare since 1973. Address: 3586 Indianola Ave, Columbus, OH 43214, United States Phone Number: +1 614-268-5090 Website: Store Hours: Sunday: Closed | Monday: 3:30-9PM | Tuesday: 3:30-9PM | Wednesday: 3:30-9PM | Thursday: 3:30-9PM | Friday: 3:30-9:30PM …
Iacono’s Pizza & Restaurant Description: . Address: 4452 Kenny Rd, Columbus, OH 43220, United States Phone Number: +1 614-451-0234 Website: http://www.iaconos.com/ Store Hours: Sunday: 4-10PM | Monday: Closed | Tuesday: 4-9PM | Wednesday: 4-9PM | Thursday: 4-9PM | Friday: 4-10PM | Saturday: 4-10PM
Piada Italian Street Food Description: Customizable Italian fast food. Counter-order chain serving design-your-own Italian food including wraps, pastas & salads. Address: 5436 Westpointe Plaza Drive, Columbus, OH 43228, United States Phone Number: +1 614-219-1788 Website: https://mypiada.com/menu/hilliard Store Hours: Sunday: 10:45AM-10PM | Monday: 10:45AM-10PM | Tuesday: 10:45AM-10PM | Wednesday: 10:45AM-10PM | Thursday: 10:45AM-10PM | Friday: 10:45AM-10PM …
Figlio Description: Modern Italian trattoria with a patio. Updated brick-oven pies & modern Italian cuisine in a space that’s equally date- & family-friendly. Address: 1369 Grandview Ave, Columbus, OH 43212, United States Phone Number: +1 614-481-8850 Website: http://figliopizza.com/ Store Hours: Sunday: Closed | Monday: 5-8:30PM | Tuesday: 5-8:30PM | Wednesday: 5-8:30PM | Thursday: 5-8:30PM | …
Borgata Pizza Cafe Description: Simple counter serve for pies & more. Unadorned counter serve dishing out NYC-style pies & ample portions of house-made pastas. Address: 5701 Parkville St, Columbus, OH 43229, United States Phone Number: +1 614-891-2345 Website: http://www.borgatapizzacafe.com/ Store Hours: Sunday: Closed | Monday: 4-10PM | Tuesday: 4-10PM | Wednesday: 4-10PM | Thursday: 4-10PM …
Piada Italian Street Food Description: Customizable Italian fast food. Counter-order chain serving design-your-own Italian food including wraps, pastas & salads. Address: 2585 E Main St, Columbus, OH 43209, United States Phone Number: +1 614-754-1834 Website: https://mypiada.com/menu/bexley Store Hours: Sunday: 10:45AM-10PM | Monday: 10:45AM-10PM | Tuesday: 10:45AM-10PM | Wednesday: 10:45AM-10PM | Thursday: 10:45AM-10PM | Friday: 10:45AM-10PM …
Piada Italian Street Food Description: Customizable Italian fast food. Counter-order chain serving design-your-own Italian food including wraps, pastas & salads. Address: 4697 Morse Rd, Columbus, OH 43230, United States Phone Number: +1 614-532-5073 Website: https://mypiada.com/menu/gahanna Store Hours: Sunday: 10:45AM-10PM | Monday: 10:45AM-10PM | Tuesday: 10:45AM-10PM | Wednesday: 10:45AM-10PM | Thursday: 10:45AM-10PM | Friday: 10:45AM-10PM | …
Marcella’s Description: Bustling trattoria offering classic fare. Lively, group-friendly kitchen serving pizza, pasta & other Italian standards in cozy surrounds. Address: 1319 Polaris Pkwy, Columbus, OH 43240, United States Phone Number: +1 614-844-6500 Website: Marcella’s Polaris Store Hours: Sunday: 11AM-9PM | Monday: 11:30AM-9PM | Tuesday: 11:30AM-9PM | Wednesday: 11:30AM-9PM | Thursday: 11:30AM-9PM | Friday: 11:30AM-10PM …
Brio Italian Grille Description: Bright & airy Italian chain restaurant. Warm, relaxed Italian eatery serving Tuscan-inspired grill fare, wine & cocktails. Address: 1500 Polaris Pkwy, Columbus, OH 43240, United States Phone Number: +1 614-410-0310 Website: Home Store Hours: Sunday: 11AM-10PM | Monday: 11AM-10PM | Tuesday: 11AM-10PM | Wednesday: 11AM-10PM | Thursday: 11AM-10PM | Friday: 11AM-10PM …
Carsonie’s Stromboli & Pizza Description: Standard Italian meals in a warm setting. Villa-style eatery with a patio serving up classic pies, stromboli & pasta dishes in a homey space. Address: 1725 W Lane Ave, Columbus, OH 43221, United States Phone Number: +1 614-481-5555 Website: http://www.carsonies.com/ Store Hours: Sunday: 12-9PM | Monday: 11AM-10PM | Tuesday: 11AM-10PM …
Carfagna’s Ristorante Description: Comfortable option for Italian classics. Traditional pastas, pizzas & other Italian fare offered in a roomy, modest setting with a full bar. Address: 1440 Gemini Pl, Columbus, OH 43240, United States Phone Number: +1 614-848-4488 Website: Home Store Hours: Sunday: Closed | Monday: 11AM-9PM | Tuesday: 11AM-9PM | Wednesday: 11AM-9PM | Thursday: …
Piada Italian Street Food Description: Customizable Italian fast food. Counter-order chain serving design-your-own Italian food including wraps, pastas & salads. Address: 1315 W Lane Ave, Columbus, OH 43221, United States Phone Number: +1 614-754-1702 Website: https://mypiada.com/menu/upper-arlington Store Hours: Sunday: 10:45AM-10PM | Monday: 10:45AM-10PM | Tuesday: 10:45AM-10PM | Wednesday: 10:45AM-10PM | Thursday: 10:45AM-10PM | Friday: 10:45AM-10PM …
Piada Italian Street Food Description: Customizable Italian fast food. Counter-order chain serving design-your-own Italian food including wraps, pastas & salads. Address: 4025 Easton Station, Columbus, OH 43219, United States Phone Number: +1 614-532-6551 Website: https://mypiada.com/menu/easton Store Hours: Sunday: 10:45AM-9PM | Monday: 10:45AM-9PM | Tuesday: 10:45AM-9PM | Wednesday: 10:45AM-9PM | Thursday: 10:45AM-9PM | Friday: 10:45AM-9PM | …
Claudiana Italian Restaurant Description: Intimate family-owned Italian cafe & bar. White-tablecloth cafe with a relaxed, intimate vibe offering homestyle Italian cuisine & a full bar. Address: 8475 Sancus Blvd, Columbus, OH 43240, United States Phone Number: +1 614-846-2236 Website: Home Store Hours: Sunday: Closed | Monday: 5-9PM | Tuesday: 5-9PM | Wednesday: 5-9PM | Thursday: …
Caffe DaVinci Description: Casual Italian spot with homemade gelato. Family-run, traditional Italian eatery serving fresh pastas, thin-crust pizza & housemade gelato. Address: 3080 Tremont Rd # B, Columbus, OH 43221, United States Phone Number: +1 614-459-9945 Website: http://www.caffedavinciua.com/ Store Hours: Sunday: 4-8PM | Monday: 11AM-8PM | Tuesday: 11AM-8PM | Wednesday: 11AM-8PM | Thursday: 11AM-8PM | …
TAT Ristorante Di Famiglia Description: Longtime staple for Italian classics. Long-running stop serving classic Italian fare (plus some American eats), with early-bird specials. Address: 1210 S James Rd, Columbus, OH 43227, United States Phone Number: +1 614-236-1392 Website: https://www.tatitalianrestaurantcolumbus.com/ Store Hours: Sunday: 12-8PM | Monday: Closed | Tuesday: Closed | Wednesday: 11AM-8PM | Thursday: 11AM-8PM …